Winners: Chris Bell out the gate knew his details, knew his programs, and was very personable. Sylvester Turner also kept his base happy, and in particular kept bringing questions of equity and access for the whole city to the fore.
King burnished his fiscally-conservative-curmudgeon badge. If that's your thing.
Losers: McVey was out of his depth. Also Ben Hall for not even showing up (though apparently it was due to some kind of medical event, so that gets a pass).
The rest: they all convinced me they want the job more than they want to do the job. That goes double for Adrian Garcia.